| Our Lady of Pity | Bronx | The Bronx | 1914 | 1910 |
| Sacred Heart | Bronx | The Bronx | 1875 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Bronx | The Bronx | 1904 | 1920 |
| Holy Spirit | Bronx | The Bronx | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Anthony, Richardson Avenue | Bronx | The Bronx | 1917 | 1920 |
| St Athanasius | Bronx | The Bronx | 1907 | 1920 |
| St Jerome | Bronx | The Bronx | 1869 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of the Scapular of Mount Carmel | Manhattan | New York County | 1884 | 1920 |
| Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary | Manhattan | New York County | 1916 | 1920 |
| St Gabriel | Manhattan | New York County | 1859 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Sorrows | Manhattan | New York County | 1867 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Loretto | Manhattan | New York County | 1891 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Manhattan | New York County | 1840 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Manhattan | New York County | 1855 | 1920 |
| St Mary Magdalen | Manhattan | New York County | 1873 | 1920 |
| Most Holy Redeemer | Manhattan | New York County | 1844 | 1920 |
| St Nicholas | Manhattan | New York County | 1833 | 1920 |
| Most Holy Redeemer | Manhattan | New York County | 1859 | 1915 |
| St Agnes | Manhattan | New York County | 1873 | 1920 |
| Mary Help of Christians | Manhattan | New York County | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Boniface | Manhattan | New York County | 1858 | 1920 |
| Nativity | Manhattan | New York County | 1842 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Grace | Manhattan | New York County | 1898 | 1920 |
| St Thomas the Apostle | Manhattan | New York County | 1889 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Manhattan | New York County | 1884 | 1920 |
| Annunciation | Manhattan | New York County | 1853 | 1920 |
| Our Lady Queen of Angels | Manhattan | New York County | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Lucy | Manhattan | New York County | 1900 | 1920 |
| Corpus Christi | Manhattan | New York County | 1906 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Jesus | Manhattan | New York County | 1868 | 1920 |
| Ascension | Manhattan | New York County | 1895 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Esperanza | Manhattan | New York County | 1912 | 1920 |
| Notre Dame | Manhattan | New York County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Gregory the Great | Manhattan | New York County | 1908 | 1920 |
| St Catherine of Genoa | Manhattan | New York County | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Rose of Lima | Manhattan | New York County | 1901 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Lourdes | Manhattan | New York County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Teresa of Avila | Sleepy Hollow & North Tarrytown | Westchester County | 1853 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Perpetual Help | Manhattan | New York County | 1874 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Bronx | The Bronx | 1853 | 1920 |
| Blessed Sacrament | Manhattan | New York County | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Matthew | Manhattan | New York County | 1902 | 1920 |
| St Cecilia | Manhattan | New York County | 1893 | 1920 |
| Holy Rosary | Manhattan | New York County | 1884 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Peace | Manhattan | New York County | 1918 | 1920 |
| All Saints | Manhattan | New York County | 1880 | 1920 |
| St Aloysius | Manhattan | New York County | 1899 | 1920 |
| St James | Milton | Ulster County | 1886 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Amenia | Dutchess County | 1868 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Wurtsboro | Sullivan County | 1882 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Marlboro | Ulster County | 1874 | 1920 |
| St John | West Hurley Woodstock | Ulster County | 1867 | 1920 |
| Presentation of the Blessed Virgin Mary | Port Ewen | Ulster County | 1873 | 1920 |
| St Francis de Sales | Phoenicia | Ulster County | 1893 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Esopus | Ulster County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Thomas Aquinas | Forestburgh | Sullivan County | 1897 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Stony Point | Rockland County | 1860 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Manhattan | New York County | 1787 | 1920 |
| St Paul the Apostle | Manhattan | New York County | 1859 | 1920 |
| St Patrick's Cathedral | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1879 | 1920 |
| Most Precious Blood | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1891 | 1920 |
| Epiphany | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Sebastian | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1915 | 1920 |
| St Joachim | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1888 | 1920 |
| St James | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1836 | 1920 |
| St Mary, Grand Street | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1833 | 1908 |
| St Rose | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1868 | 1920 |
| St Ann, East 12th Street | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Brigid | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1849 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus B & M | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1881 | 1920 |
| St Stephen | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1849 | 1920 |
| Basilica of St Patrick Old Cathedral | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1838 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mercy | Bronx | The Bronx | 1919 | 1920 |
| Holy Family | Bronx | The Bronx | 1896 | 1920 |
| St Anthony, Commonwealth Avenue | Bronx | The Bronx | 1908 | 1920 |
| St Frances of Rome | Bronx | The Bronx | 1908 | 1920 |
| St Raymond | Bronx | The Bronx | 1853 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mercy | Bronx | The Bronx | 1855 | 1919 |
| St Francis of Assisi | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1840 | 1920 |
| St John the Baptist | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1840 | 1920 |
| St Francis Xavier | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1851 | 1920 |
| St Malachy | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1902 | 1920 |
| SS Cyril & Methodius | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Clare | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1903 | 1920 |
| St Raphael | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Ann | Nyack | Rockland County | 1870 | 1920 |
| St Catharine | Blauvelt | Rockland County | 1870 | 1920 |
| St Paul | Congers | Rockland County | 1896 | 1920 |
| St Michael the Archangel | Rockland Lake | Rockland County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Teresa | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1865 | 1920 |
| St Vincent de Paul | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1842 | 1920 |
| St Cyril | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1916 | 1920 |
| St Joseph, Monroe Street | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1907 | 1920 |
| Transfiguration | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1825 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart, Roosevelt & Welfare Islands | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1909 | 1920 |
| St Andrew | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1842 | 1920 |
| St Benedict the Moor | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1883 | 1920 |
| St Columba | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1848 | 1920 |
| St Bernard | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1868 | 1916 |
| St Alphonsus | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1888 | 1920 |
| St Veronica | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Anthony | Nanuet | Rockland County | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Joseph of the Holy Family | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1893 | 1920 |
| St Stephen of Hungary | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Francis de Sales | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1894 | 1920 |
| St Michael | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1857 | 1920 |
| Blessed Sacrament | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1910 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Good Counsel | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1899 | 1920 |
| Our Lady Help of Christians | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1898 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1887 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Ann | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1914 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1875 | 1920 |
| St Adalbert | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Anthony of Padua | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Clement | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St John Baptist de la Salle | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1900 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of the Rosary | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1887 | 1920 |
| SS Joseph & Thomas | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1853 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Mary of the Assumption | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1877 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1839 | 1920 |
| St Patrick | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1884 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Middletown | Orange County | 1910 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Mary | Montgomery | Orange County | 1872 | 1895 |
| St Patrick | Newburgh | Orange County | 1828 | 1849 |
| St Mary | Newburgh | Orange County | 1875 | 1920 |
| St Francis of Assisi | Newburgh | Orange County | 1909 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Port Jervis | Orange County | 1856 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Port Jervis | Orange County | 1898 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Tuxedo | Orange County | 1868 | 1920 |
| Church of the Most Precious Blood | Walden | Orange County | 1912 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus | Pine Island | Orange County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Anastasia | Harriman | Orange County | 1899 | 1920 |
| Holy Cross | Callicoon | Sullivan County | 1863 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Glasco | Ulster County | 1919 | 1920 |
| St Andrew | Ellenville | Ulster County | 1878 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Washingtonville | Orange County | 1838 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Liberty | Sullivan County | 1894 | 1920 |
| St Aloysius | Livingstone Manor | Sullivan County | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Monticello | Sullivan County | 1874 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Obernburg | Sullivan County | 1850 | 1920 |
| St John | Saugerties | Ulster County | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Colman | East Kingston | Ulster County | 1904 | 1920 |
| St Charles Borromeo | Gardiner | Ulster County | 1882 | 1909 |
| St Peter | Kingston | Ulster County | 1858 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Saugerties | Ulster County | 1837 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Kingston | Ulster County | 1893 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Jesus | Kingston | Ulster County | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Kingston | Ulster County | 1868 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Kingston | Ulster County | 1841 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | New Paltz | Ulster County | 1908 | 1920 |
| Nativity | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1863 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1873 | 1920 |
| St Joachim | Beacon | Dutchess County | 1853 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Bangall | Dutchess County | 1919 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Beacon | Dutchess County | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1837 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Millbrook | Dutchess County | 1890 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus | Pleasant Valley | Dutchess County | 1903 | 1920 |
| St Christopher | Red Hook | Dutchess County | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Denis | Hopewell Junction | Dutchess County | 1874 | 1920 |
| Regina Coeli | Hyde Park | Dutchess County | 1877 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Pawling | Dutchess County | 1884 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Wappingers Falls | Dutchess County | 1853 | 1920 |
| Good Shepherd | Rhinebeck | Dutchess County | 1849 | 1920 |
| St Sylvia | Tivoli | Dutchess County | 1890 | 1920 |
| St Lawrence O'Toole | Brewster | Putnam County | 1870 | 1920 |
| St Columba | Chester | Orange County | 1880 | 1920 |
| St Thomas of Canterbury | Cornwall on Hudson | Orange County | 1870 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Loretto | Cold Spring | Putnam County | 1845 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Mahopac | Putnam County | 1889 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Rosendale | Ulster County | 1855 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Goshen | Orange County | 1849 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart of Jesus | Highland Falls | Orange County | 1891 | 1920 |
| Assumption | Maybrook | Orange County | 1907 | 1920 |
| St Stephen | Warwick | Orange County | 1889 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Middletown | Orange County | 1865 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Florida | Orange County | 1895 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Newburgh | Orange County | 1912 | 1920 |
| St Joseph, Sixth Avenue | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1833 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Haverstraw | Rockland County | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Haverstraw | Rockland County | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Margaret | Pearl River | Rockland County | 1894 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Suffern | Rockland County | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Spring Valley | Rockland County | 1896 | 1920 |
| St John | Piermont | Rockland County | 1851 | 1920 |
| St Anthony of Padua | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1866 | 1920 |
| St Alphonsus | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1847 | 1888 |
| Holy Family | New Rochelle | Westchester County | 1913 | 1920 |
| Resurrection | Rye | Westchester County | 1880 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mercy | Port Chester | Westchester County | 1854 | 1911 |
| Sacred Heart of Jesus | Port Chester | Westchester County | 1912 | 1920 |
| Assumption | Tuckahoe | Westchester County | 1911 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Tuckahoe | Westchester County | 1868 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of the Rosary | Port Chester | Westchester County | 1902 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Mary | Croton-on-Hudson | Westchester County | 1877 | 1920 |
| St Joseph Parish | Somers & Croton Falls | Westchester County | 1853 | 1920 |
| St Mary of the Assumption | Katonah | Westchester County | 1902 | 1920 |
| Holy Rosary | Hawthorne | Westchester County | 1909 | 1920 |
| Assumption | Peekskill | Westchester County | 1858 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Heart of Mary | Scarsdale | Westchester County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Augustine | Ossining | Westchester County | 1855 | 1920 |
| St Patrick | Verplanck | Westchester County | 1844 | 1920 |
| Holy Innocents | Pleasantville | Westchester County | 1894 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception, Gun Hill Road | Bronx | The Bronx | 1902 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Bronx | The Bronx | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Mary Star of the Seas | Bronx | The Bronx | 1898 | 1920 |
| St Barnabas | Bronx | The Bronx | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Brendan | Bronx | The Bronx | 1908 | 1920 |
| St John | Bronx | The Bronx | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Valentine | Bronx | The Bronx | 1891 | 1920 |
| St Margaret of Cortona | Bronx | The Bronx | 1908 | 1920 |
| St Philip Neri | Bronx | The Bronx | 1898 | 1920 |
| St John the Baptist | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1819 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception & St Mary | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1847 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of the Rosary | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1907 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Anthony, Willow Street | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1900 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1871 | 1920 |
| St Anthony, Nepara Park | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Denis | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Ursula | Mount Vernon | Westchester County | 1908 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Mount Vernon | Westchester County | 1897 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Dobbs Ferry | Westchester County | 1872 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Mount Vernon | Westchester County | 1894 | 1920 |
| Holy Eucharist | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1909 | 1920 |
| St Catharine Parish | Pelham | Westchester County | 1897 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Victory | Mount Vernon | Westchester County | 1874 | 1885 |
| Immaculate Conception | Irvington-on-Hudson | Westchester County | 1873 | 1920 |
| St Matthew | Hastings-on-Hudson | Westchester County | 1892 | 1920 |
| Most Holy Trinity | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1894 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1894 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Yonkers | Westchester County | 1891 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus Kostka | Hastings-on-Hudson | Westchester County | 1914 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | New Rochelle | Westchester County | 1901 | 1920 |
| The Magdalene | Pocantico Hills | Westchester County | 1894 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Jesus | Valhalla | Westchester County | 1897 | 1920 |
| Holy Cross | Sleepy Hollow & North Tarrytown | Westchester County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Gregory the Great | Harrison | Westchester County | 1911 | 1920 |
| St Gabriel | New Rochelle | Westchester County | 1893 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Elmsford | Westchester County | 1905 | 1920 |
| Church of the Transfiguration | Tarrytown | Westchester County | 1896 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | White Plains | Westchester County | 1868 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | White Plains | Westchester County | 1902 | 1920 |
| Most Holy Trinity | Mamaroneck | Westchester County | 1814 | 1920 |
| St Augustine | Larchmont | Westchester County | 1892 | 1920 |
| St Vito | Mamaroneck | Westchester County | 1907 | 1920 |
| St Angela Merici | Bronx | The Bronx | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Anselm | Bronx | The Bronx | 1891 | 1920 |
| St John Chrysostom | Bronx | The Bronx | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Martin of Tours | Bronx | The Bronx | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Adelbert | Bronx | The Bronx | 1898 | 1903 |
| St Joseph | Bronx | The Bronx | 1874 | 1920 |
| St Nicholas of Tolentine | Bronx | The Bronx | 1906 | 1920 |
| St Augustine | Bronx | The Bronx | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Pius V | Bronx | The Bronx | 1882 | 1920 |
| St Luke | Bronx | The Bronx | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Simon Stock | Bronx | The Bronx | 1920 | 1920 |
| St Roch | Bronx | The Bronx | 1908 | 1911 |
| St Roch | Bronx | The Bronx | 1914 | 1918 |
| St Roch | Bronx | The Bronx | 1918 | 1920 |
| St Paul | Manhattan | New York County | 1834 | 1920 |
| St Thomas Aquinas | Bronx | The Bronx | 1889 | 1920 |
| St Mark the Evangelist | Manhattan | New York County | 1907 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Solace | Bronx | The Bronx | 1903 | 1920 |
| St Charles Borromeo | Manhattan | New York County | 1888 | 1920 |
| St Catherine of Siena | Manhattan | New York County | 1897 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart of Jesus | Manhattan | New York County | 1876 | 1920 |
| Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary | Manhattan | New York County | 1858 | 1920 |
| St Ambrose | Manhattan | New York County | 1898 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Vilna | Manhattan | New York County | 1902 | 1920 |
| St Elizabeth of Hungary | Manhattan | New York County | 1891 | 1906 |
| St Ignatius Loyola | Manhattan | New York County | 1865 | 1894 |
| St Jean Baptiste | Manhattan | New York County | 1882 | 1920 |
| St John Nepomucene | Manhattan | New York County | 1895 | 1920 |
| St Monica | Manhattan | New York County | 1880 | 1920 |
| St Vincent Ferrer | Manhattan | New York County | 1867 | 1920 |
| Incarnation | Manhattan | New York County | 1908 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Victory | Bronx | The Bronx | 1909 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Good Counsel | Manhattan | New York County | 1886 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of the Scapular of Mount Carmel | Manhattan | New York County | 1889 | 1920 |
| St Anthony of Padua | Bronx | The Bronx | 1903 | 1920 |
| St Joseph, East 87th Street | Manhattan | New York County | 1859 | 1920 |
| St John the Martyr | Manhattan | New York County | 1902 | 1920 |
| Good Shepherd | Manhattan | New York County | 1913 | 1920 |
| Our Savior | Bronx | The Bronx | 1912 | 1920 |
| SS Peter & Paul | Bronx | The Bronx | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Ann, East 110th Street | Bronx | The Bronx | 1904 | 1920 |
| Holy Cross | Manhattan | New York County | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Clemens Mary | Manhattan | New York County | 1909 | 1920 |
| Holy Trinity | Manhattan | New York County | 1899 | 1920 |
| Central Harlem, Resurrection | Central Harlem | New York County | 1907 | 1920 |
| Central Harlem, St Joseph of the Holy Family | Central Harlem | New York County | 1860 | 1892 |
| Northwest Bronx, St Margaret of Cortona | Bronx | The Bronx | 1889 | 1908 |
| Ulster County, St Andrew | Ellenville | Ulster County | 1850 | 1878 |
| St Francis de Sales | Phoenicia | Ulster County | 1893 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Esopus | Ulster County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Thomas Aquinas | Forestburgh | Sullivan County | 1897 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Stony Point | Rockland County | 1860 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Manhattan | New York County | 1787 | 1920 |
| St Paul the Apostle | Manhattan | New York County | 1859 | 1920 |
| St Patrick's Cathedral | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1879 | 1920 |
| Most Precious Blood | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1891 | 1920 |
| Epiphany | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Sebastian | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1915 | 1920 |
| St Joachim | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1888 | 1920 |
| St James | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1836 | 1920 |
| St Mary, Grand Street | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1833 | 1920 |
| St Rose | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1868 | 1920 |
| St Ann, East 12th Street | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Brigid | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1849 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus Blessed Mother | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1881 | 1920 |
| St Stephen | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1849 | 1920 |
| Basilica of St Patrick Old Cathedral | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1838 | 1920 |
| St Francis of Assisi | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1840 | 1920 |
| St John the Baptist | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1840 | 1920 |
| St Francis Xavier | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1851 | 1920 |
| St Malachy | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1902 | 1920 |
| SS Cyril & Methodius | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Clare | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1903 | 1920 |
| St Raphael | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Ann | Nyack | Rockland County | 1870 | 1920 |
| St Catharine | Blauvelt | Rockland County | 1870 | 1920 |
| St Paul | Congers | Rockland County | 1896 | 1920 |
| St Michael the Archangel | Rockland Lake | Rockland County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Teresa | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1865 | 1920 |
| St Vincent de Paul | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1842 | 1920 |
| St Cyril | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1916 | 1920 |
| St Joseph, Monroe Street | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1907 | 1920 |
| Transfiguration | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1825 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart, Roosevelt & Welfare Islands | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1909 | 1920 |
| St Andrew | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1842 | 1920 |
| St Benedict the Moor | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1883 | 1920 |
| St Columba | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1848 | 1920 |
| St Bernard | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1868 | 1916 |
| St Alphonsus | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1888 | 1920 |
| St Veronica | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Anthony | Nanuet | Rockland County | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Joseph of the Holy Family | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1893 | 1920 |
| St Stephen of Hungary | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Francis de Sales | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1894 | 1920 |
| St Michael | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1857 | 1920 |
| Blessed Sacrament | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1910 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Good Counsel | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1899 | 1920 |
| Our Lady Help of Christians | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1898 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1887 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Ann | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1914 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1875 | 1920 |
| St Adalbert | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1852 | 1920 |
| St Anthony of Padua | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St Clement | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1910 | 1920 |
| St John Baptist de la Salle | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1900 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of the Rosary | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1887 | 1920 |
| SS Joseph & Thomas | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1853 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Mary of the Assumption | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1877 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1839 | 1920 |
| St Patrick | Staten Island | Richmond County | 1884 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1910 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Middletown | Orange County | 1911 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Mary | Montgomery | Orange County | 1872 | 1895 |
| St Patrick | Newburgh | Orange County | 1828 | 1849 |
| St Mary | Newburgh | Orange County | 1875 | 1920 |
| St Francis of Assisi | Newburgh | Orange County | 1909 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Port Jervis | Orange County | 1856 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Port Jervis | Orange County | 1898 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Mount Carmel | Tuxedo | Orange County | 1868 | 1920 |
| Church of the Most Precious Blood | Walden | Orange County | 1912 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus | Pine Island | Orange County | 1913 | 1920 |
| St Anastasia | Harriman | Orange County | 1899 | 1920 |
| Holy Cross | Callicoon | Sullivan County | 1863 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Glasco | Ulster County | 1919 | 1920 |
| St Andrew | Ellenville | Ulster County | 1878 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Ellenville | Ulster County | 1838 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Washingtonville | Orange County | 1902 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Liberty | Sullivan County | 1894 | 1920 |
| St Aloysius | Livingstone Manor | Sullivan County | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Monticello | Sullivan County | 1874 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Obernburg | Sullivan County | 1850 | 1920 |
| St John | Saugerties | Ulster County | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Colman | East Kingston | Ulster County | 1904 | 1920 |
| St Charles Borromeo | Gardiner | Ulster County | 1882 | 1909 |
| St Peter | Kingston | Ulster County | 1858 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Saugerties | Ulster County | 1837 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Kingston | Ulster County | 1893 | 1920 |
| Holy Name of Jesus | Kingston | Ulster County | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Kingston | Ulster County | 1868 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Kingston | Ulster County | 1841 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | New Paltz | Ulster County | 1908 | 1920 |
| Nativity | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1863 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1901 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1873 | 1920 |
| St Joachim | Beacon | Dutchess County | 1853 | 1920 |
| Immaculate Conception | Bangall | Dutchess County | 1919 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Beacon | Dutchess County | 1887 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Poughkeepsie | Dutchess County | 1896 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Millbrook | Dutchess County | 1890 | 1920 |
| St Stanislaus | Pleasant Valley | Dutchess County | 1903 | 1920 |
| St Christopher | Red Hook | Dutchess County | 1886 | 1920 |
| St Denis | Hopewell Junction | Dutchess County | 1874 | 1920 |
| Regina Coeli | Hyde Park | Dutchess County | 1877 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Pawling | Dutchess County | 1884 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Wappingers Falls | Dutchess County | 1853 | 1920 |
| Good Shepherd | Rhinebeck | Dutchess County | 1849 | 1920 |
| St Sylvia | Tivoli | Dutchess County | 1890 | 1920 |
| St Lawrence O'Toole | Brewster | Putnam County | 1870 | 1920 |
| St Columba | Chester | Orange County | 1880 | 1920 |
| St Thomas of Canterbury | Cornwall on Hudson | Orange County | 1870 | 1920 |
| Our Lady of Loretto | Cold Spring | Putnam County | 1845 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Mahopac | Putnam County | 1889 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Rosendale | Ulster County | 1855 | 1920 |
| St John the Evangelist | Goshen | Orange County | 1849 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart of Jesus | Highland Falls | Orange County | 1891 | 1920 |
| Assumption | Maybrook | Orange County | 1907 | 1920 |
| St Stephen | Warwick | Orange County | 1889 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Middletown | Orange County | 1865 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Florida | Orange County | 1895 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Newburgh | Orange County | 1912 | 1920 |
| St Joseph, Sixth Avenue | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1833 | 1920 |
| St Peter | Haverstraw | Rockland County | 1852 | 1908 |
| St Peter | Haverstraw | Rockland County | 1908 | 1920 |
| St Mary | Haverstraw | Rockland County | 1899 | 1920 |
| St Margaret | Pearl River | Rockland County | 1894 | 1920 |
| Sacred Heart | Suffern | Rockland County | 1897 | 1920 |
| St Joseph | Spring Valley | Rockland County | 1896 | 1920 |
| St John | Piermont | Rockland County | 1851 | 1920 |
| St Anthony of Padua | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1866 | 1920 |
| St Alphonsus | Manhattan | Manhattan | 1847 | 1888 |